Here’s a possible conversation between Epicurus and St. Justin the Martyr about the nature of love:
Epicurus: Love is a natural emotion that arises from our innate desire for pleasure and happiness. We love things that bring us pleasure and avoid things that cause us pain.
St. Justin the Martyr: I disagree, love is not just a matter of seeking pleasure. True love involves self-sacrifice and putting the needs of others before our own desires.
Epicurus: But why should we put the needs of others before our own? If we’re always sacrificing our own pleasure for the sake of others, we’ll never be truly happy.
St. Justin the Martyr: Love is not just about our own happiness. It’s about caring for others and sharing in their joys and sorrows. By putting others first, we can experience a deeper sense of fulfillment and purpose in life.
Epicurus: I see your point. Perhaps there is a way to reconcile our views. Love can be both a natural emotion that arises from our desire for pleasure, and a selfless act of caring for others. It’s possible to love someone for the pleasure they bring us, and also to love them for who they are and how they make us better people.
St. Justin the Martyr: Yes, that’s exactly right. Love is complex and multifaceted, and it can take many different forms. Ultimately, it’s about valuing and cherishing the people and things that matter to us, whether that involves seeking our own pleasure or sacrificing for the sake of others.
Epicurus: Agreed. Love is a beautiful and powerful force that can enrich our lives and bring us closer to the things that matter most.